Author:
Psycasm | Views: 1453 |
Comments: 9 Last by Psycasm on Jan 17, 2011, 11:04pm
Who knows the trolley dilemma?
It's a simple little thought experiment in ethics. Here's a variation:
You are a station master at a railway and a runaway train is speeding through the station. Ahead of it is a split line, and the train is headed down Line A if you do not act. At the end of Line A is a single surveyor, inspecting the tracks, oblivious to the fact there is a train headed for him. At the end of Line B is a group of 4 or 5 workmen doing some maintenance.
You cannot stop the train, but you can redirect it down Line B. Do you?
Most people will answer No. It's a tragedy, but the loss of one life is better than the loss of 5.
You are a station master at a railway and a runaway train is speeding through the station. Ahead of it is a split line, and the train is headed down Line A if you do not act. At the end of Line A is a group of 4 or 5 workmen doing some maintenance, oblivious to the fact there is a train headed for them. At the end of Line B is a single surveyor, inspecting the tracks.
You cannot stop the train, but you can redirect it down Line B. Do you?
Many people will answer Yes for the same reason. The loss of one life is a tragedy, yet your a . . .
More